Case 001 · United Kingdom · Verified
Nine months, a fee paid, samples shipped, banking details handed over — and not one unit ordered.
- Business
- DEOfferent UK Ltd — Lifelong Deo
- Product
- Refillable deodorant — applicators and powder refills
- Submitted by
- Adam Webb, Founder
In January 2026 OG Global Import approached Lifelong Deo, a British refillable deodorant brand, about distribution in Israel under its retail brand Fine Rituals.
Over the following nine months the brand dealt with eleven different people at the company, paid a regulatory fee, shipped samples at its own cost, supplied its full company banking details, agreed a price list and submitted a completed first order.
Fine Rituals Ltd registered the product properly with the Israeli Ministry of Health in July 2026 — all ten colourways, with Lifelong named as the foreign manufacturer. Everything needed to begin trading was in place.
No units have been ordered.
What was committed
A purchase schedule was set out covering twelve months, quarter by quarter:
| Period | Units | Value |
|---|---|---|
| Twelve months | About 6,000 | About £100,000 |
A quarterly purchase schedule set out in the signed agreement. Exact quantities and prices are not published because the agreement's terms are confidential.
What happened, in order
7 January 2026
First approach by cold email, headed “Distribution Opportunity for Lifelongdeo in Asia”.
January – February
Introductory calls on 16, 23 and 28 January, follow-ups on 12 and 18 February. Lab test documentation supplied on 25 February.
1 March
A team introduction call. Six colleagues invited.
2 March
A regulatory fee requested for a Ministry of Health submission, with a same-day deadline. Two banks — Wise and Starling — independently blocked the transfer. The payment, $3,583.43 in total ($3,550 to Fine Rituals Ltd plus $33.43 in transfer fees), was made from a personal Revolut account instead.
2 March
The supplier's full company banking details requested: account name, account number, IBAN, SWIFT and bank address. The stated reason was to open a trading account for handling payments on future purchase orders.
5 March
Banking details supplied and receipt confirmed.
6 April
Samples shipped by the supplier at its own cost. A commercial invoice provided for customs.
16 July
Ministry of Health notification 1672026203949 issued, covering all ten colourways, with Lifelong named as the foreign manufacturer. Collection of stock from the supplier's warehouse in Estonia proposed for the following week.
4 September
Eight months after first contact, the company wrote that the product under discussion was still unsettled: “right now two different products are being discussed as if they're one”.
16 September
The supplier's stock position confirmed. The first order could proceed.
29 September
A completed first order submitted: 250 refills per scent and 50 units of each applicator.
5 October
Chased. Reply: a colleague was unwell.
11 October
Chased again. Reply: it was the weekend and the sender was away.
October
ogglobalimport.com stopped showing its own site and began redirecting to fine-rituals.com. Asked why, Dana Zilberstein said it had been taken down after a cyberattack. References to OG Global were also no longer visible on the company's LinkedIn profiles; Ofri Shaysh called that point “unrelated”.
22 October
Ofri Shaysh wrote: “We'll have the PO to you shortly.” No purchase order followed.
30 October
After further chasing, the supplier's messages became heated and used the word “scam”. Dana Zilberstein replied that the company was seeking legal advice on terminating the contract, citing “threats and inappropriate communication”. Later the same day Ofri Shaysh wrote that the company was “ready to move forward” on one product line only.
November
In a FaceTime call, Dana Zilberstein told the supplier that Ofri Shaysh, her business partner, could not be contacted and was not answering her calls; that he was the only person who could approve purchase orders; that the company therefore could not fulfil any order; that she was looking for an investor; and that she had been paying staff from her own pocket. This is the supplier's account of a verbal conversation. No purchase order has been placed.
November
The supplier has since been blocked on LinkedIn: the profiles of the company's founders now return “This page doesn't exist” to the supplier's account, while still showing normally to other visitors.
What each side gave
The single thing another brand should look at hardest. Every step forward cost the supplier something, and none of them cost the distributor anything.
| They asked for | The supplier gave |
|---|---|
| A regulatory submission fee | $3,583.43, paid from a personal account after two banks refused |
| Samples | Product, shipped at the supplier's expense |
| A commercial invoice | Provided |
| Company banking details | Account number, IBAN and SWIFT, in plain text |
| A completed first order | Submitted |
Against that, what was received was documents, meetings and assurances. No order, no stock movement, no revenue.
What this brand would tell another
- If your bank refuses a payment, stop and find out why. Two refused here, and both were worked around rather than questioned.
- Don't send full banking details by email because a distributor asks for them to “set up a trading account”. A distributor does not need your IBAN to place an order with you.
- Verify regulatory approvals yourself, at source. In this case the registration was genuine — but a PDF with a notification number on it is not an approval until the issuing authority confirms it.
- A registration being real does not mean the trading will follow. The paperwork was complete in July. Nothing was ordered after it.
- The sequence to recognise: a working retail website and a marketplace shop selling other brands; a signed agreement with large purchase targets; a registration fee paid by the brand; a genuine registration; and then no order. If a distributor asks you to fund registration before it has placed and paid for any order, ask for a paid purchase order or a deposit first.
In fairness
Fine Rituals Ltd is a genuine registered Israeli company, active and with no violation flags, and it did file the Ministry of Health registration properly. Those documents are published on this site. This account concerns what did not happen afterwards.
The Ministry of Health registrations →